“A bright star in this performance was Fletcher's vocally alluring Pelléas played with a precision and transparency of innocence.”
— Farmington Valley Herald
“...superb.”
— American Record Guide
“...vocal quality at once youthful, virile, impassioned and seductive, with Fletcher moving through notes of all altitudes with unflinching confidence and security… his singing can stand comparison with the best...”
— Hartford Courant
“As Don Quixote, Paul Laurence Fletcher - enjoyed earlier this season as Joe Hardy in Damn Yankees - combined a handsomely legitimate baritone voice with poised acting ability to carry yet another show successfully and with polish.”
— East Haddam Trumpeter